Welcome to Redesign Malaysia: For Better Broadband, For the Rakyat. - Internet, Broadband, Malaysia, WiFi, Wireless, WiMax, Streamyx, Jaring and more…

This website is an initiative to improve Malaysia’s broadband facilities. It contains a broadband coverage map, articles on Malaysia broadband, comparisions of internet service providers and feature articles.

Redesign Malaysia is an initiative to improve Malaysia's broadband internet penetration, quality and reliability.We aim to achieve this through the compilation of relevant news articles, allowing users to have a voice, enlightening consumers on the options that are available, providing comparative statistics on ISPs, as well as the production of special features and commentary.


It is designed to be a community effort, to utilize information and feedback from broadband users and potential customers across Malaysia. We also aim to gain cooperation from the various broadband players in Malaysia, as well as support from government agencies and regulators.


Currently, we are focused on the Klang Valley, however in time we aim to expand this initiative nationwide. Let's all collaborate - to make fast, cheap and efficient broadband available throughout Malaysia.



isplist
showhidebutton

RedesignMalaysia.com Partner
Advertlets.com
Website Features
features01
Links


by Josh Lim
February 9 2007 || 10:36 am

A great, surprisingly unrestrained editorial in The Star. A. Asohan comments in The Star (In Tech), about the recent throttling exercise carried out by Malaysian ISPs. He starts the article with a metaphor as of such: Errant motorists are causing havoc on the roads - so, automobile manufacturers announce that they will limit the maximum speeds of their cars.

Quote: Datuk, this baby’s got a 400-horsepower, 12-cylinder engine that’ll take you from 0 to 140kph in five seconds! Oh, but don’t worry, we’re restricting its speed to 60kph … don’t want you driving too fast now, do we? A stupid idea, right? Who would want to sell a sports car with deliberately built-in speed limits? More importantly, who would even want to buy one?
Yet a similar scenario is playing itself out in Malaysian cyberspace. After years of under-achievement in our national broadband aspirations, the network service providers are taking a couple of steps back.

It also mentioned there are rumours that TMNet Streamyx might follow Maxis Broadband’s Terms of Service, which include automatic disconnection after a period of inactivity, and a total usage per month limit. (Maxis is 3GB - which is ridiculously low, considering spending a couple of hours on YouTube can easily rack up hundreds of megabytes). This aren’t unfounded rumours - why do you think your disconnections are getting more frequent? And your traffic is being throttled? Why do you think your total monthly usage is showing up in your monthly bill?

One ISP said it found out that 1% of its users were using up 30% of its bandwidth. Some will even tell you they’re trying to combat illegal downloads and online piracy.

Terms such as “traffic shaping” and others are being bandied about. This is what ISPs in other countries are doing after they found out their services had been over-subscribed. But at least those foreign ISPs had to admit their infrastructure was not up to par.

Guys. Keep making noise, and let them know that this kind of action will not be tolerated. I have it on good word that TMNet and some of their suppliers monitor this blog. We now get close to 1000 unique visits a day, btw. Nearly half is from Google, consisting of search terms such as “maxis broadband” and “tmnet streamyx”, and the other half is from people like yourselves - the bloggers, the forumites, the gamers and more.

Consider letting (links to contact pages): The Star, The New Straits Times, The Malay Mail, The Edge, Utusan and other media publications know that you’ll like to read more about RedesignMalaysia.com in the papers - we need to take this fight offline, not just on the net.

We need to do this before TMNet starts changings its monthly terms. Not after, which will be too late.

blogbackgroundbottom
February 9 2007 || 10:36 am
Reuben said..comment

A better metaphor is that of a mamak store. You have increasing numbers of customers but still the same amount of roti canai. Instead of buying more roti canai, you give everyone a smaller piece of roti canai while charging the same price. Unlike a mamak store where we can switch to another mamak store, for many of us…we simply do not have a choice and have to make do with the smaller piece of roti canai.

February 9 2007 || 10:36 am
bk said..comment

i can’t believe that giant companies like TM and Maxis practice this! it is a sad thing happened again…again…and…again in malaysia. they always claimed that they are the best in…… and in……(advertised in newspaper). they really need to look into their after sales customer services.

February 9 2007 || 10:36 am
Awee said..comment

Possible solution is to get more people to subsribe which increase the usage and makes more money thus buy/upgrade the hardware/service.

But we don’t see any upgrade even now there are more ane more Tmnut user.

February 9 2007 || 10:36 am
Awee said..comment

On the other hand, we can bombard local media with info about the situation so more people will know/understand the situation.

February 9 2007 || 10:36 am
Reuben said..comment

Considering they are often the only ones in a lot of areas…they ARE the best which is even sadder T_T

February 9 2007 || 10:36 am
hatibudi said..comment

Expecting TM to be truthful would be like expecting snow in Malaysia.

February 9 2007 || 10:36 am

[…] The evidence is clear, TMnet is using some kind of packet shaping thing to throttle down P2P traffic. More and more people are trying to bypass it. […]

February 9 2007 || 10:36 am
Joe said..comment

TMnet is the King of monopoly..the goverment should do like Celcom streamyx, Digi streamyx, Hotlink streamyx…. so the people will have more choices when choosing their ISP. Then the service is more better because got competition from other company.
right now, streamyx is sucks… download speed is very slow 5kb/s. they should not control the bandwith because the customer paying them monthly (not Cheap). TMnet try lah to find some good solution to this bandwith problem. Dont just think about profit only but also think about your customer satisfaction.

Participate! Leave your comment.


Your Comments:




Visit our partner site, Advertlets.com - Asia's Better Blog Advertising Network to find out how you can make money with your blog, and advertise to Malaysians!